Car Insurance Comparison NZ

Compare car insurance from a panel of New Zealand insurers — comprehensive and third-party cover, excess levels and no-claim bonus.

Last updated 8 June 2026 · By MoneyGuru Editorial Team

12 NZ car insurers on file Updated 8 June 2026 Licensed via Evolve Group (FSP711891) Free, no obligation
Over 4.5 million

light vehicles registered in New Zealand

Over 4.5 million vehicles are registered in NZ — many uninsured

NZ has no compulsory third-party motor insurance, so a meaningful portion of the 4.5-million-plus light vehicle fleet carries no cover for damage to other people's cars or property. ACC handles personal injury — vehicle and property damage is on the driver.

Source:  NZ Transport Agency (Waka Kotahi / NZTA)  · New Zealand Motor Vehicle Register statistics — National vehicle fleet · verified 2026-06-09

A panel of New Zealand car insurers we compare

AA Insurance logo
State logo
Tower logo
AMI logo
Cove logo
NZI logo

Compare car insurance insurers

Showing 12 insurers on file. Cover, premiums and exclusions vary — get a tailored quote via the form below.

Insurer Products on file Last updated
1 20 May 2026
2 20 May 2026
1 20 May 2026
FMG logo FMG
2 20 May 2026
1 20 May 2026
NZI logo NZI
2 20 May 2026
1 20 May 2026
1 20 May 2026
1 20 May 2026
1 20 May 2026
1 20 May 2026
3 20 May 2026

Full product list (sortable)

17 retail products from 12 insurers. Sort by insurer / product / wording date, filter to one insurer, and link straight through to each insurer's published wording PDF.

17 products shown

car insurance products with insurer, status, and latest wording reference
Positioning
AA Insurance
AA Insurance — Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
AMI Insurance
AMI — Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
AMI Insurance
AMI — Classic Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Cove Insurance
Cove — Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
FMG
FMG — Essential Private Vehiclestatus: active20 May 2026
FMG
FMG — Vehicle Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Initio
Initio — Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
NZI
NZI — Distinction Motor Vehiclestatus: active20 May 2026
NZI
NZI — Motor Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Protecta Insurance
Protecta — Motor Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Star Insure
Star Insure — Vehicle Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
State Insurance
State — Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Tower Insurance
Tower — Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Trade Me Insurance
Trade Me Insurance — Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Vero Insurance
Vero — EverydayPlus Car Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026
Vero Insurance
Vero — InsureMyTeslastatus: active20 May 2026
Vero Insurance
Vero — Motor Insurancestatus: active20 May 2026

Source: each product row links to the insurer's published policy wording PDF. MoneyGuru does not rank or rate products — request a quote for a tailored comparison from a licensed adviser.

Car insurers compared

A short profile of each NZ car insurer on our panel.

AA Insurance logo

AA Insurance

AA-branded direct insurer

Strengths

  • Recognised brand among NZ drivers
  • Direct application and policy management
  • Roadside assistance integration for AA members
  • Comprehensive and third-party options

Considerations

  • !Premium pricing varies significantly by region and vehicle
  • !Joint venture between AA NZ and Vero (Suncorp)
Show full details

Suited to: AA members and customers preferring a recognised consumer brand.

Get a free AA Insurance quote →
State logo

State

IAG-owned direct insurer

Strengths

  • Wide NZ presence and recognition
  • Direct application and online quoting
  • Comprehensive and third-party cover
  • Backed by IAG group

Considerations

  • !Premium changes between renewals can be sharp
  • !Optional add-ons priced separately
Show full details

Suited to: Customers wanting a mainstream direct insurer.

Get a free State quote →
Tower logo

Tower

NZ-owned direct insurer

Strengths

  • NZ-headquartered insurer
  • Risk-based pricing by location
  • Comprehensive and third-party cover
  • Online policy management

Considerations

  • !Risk-based pricing means premiums vary widely by address
  • !Smaller scale than IAG-group insurers
Show full details

Suited to: Customers in lower-risk locations wanting an NZ-owned insurer.

Get a free Tower quote →
AMI logo

AMI

IAG-owned direct insurer

Strengths

  • Long-established NZ brand
  • Direct online and phone application
  • Comprehensive and third-party options
  • Wider distribution network

Considerations

  • !Part of IAG group alongside State and NZI
  • !Premium can rise sharply after a claim
Show full details

Suited to: Customers familiar with the AMI brand and direct service.

Get a free AMI quote →
Cove logo

Cove

Online-only direct insurer

Strengths

  • App-first policy management
  • Pay-by-the-month flexibility
  • Streamlined online quoting
  • NZ market entrant

Considerations

  • !Newer to the market than mainstream insurers
  • !Cover options narrower than incumbents
Show full details

Suited to: App-comfortable drivers wanting a quick online policy.

Get a free Cove quote →

Feature comparison

Side-by-side product features at a glance.

InsurerDistributionComprehensiveThird-partyRoadsideExcess rangeNo-claim bonus
AA Insurance
Direct + AA channelAvailableAvailableAdd-onLow to high rangeYes
State
DirectAvailableAvailableAdd-onLow to high rangeYes
Tower
DirectAvailableAvailableAdd-onLow to high rangeYes
AMI
DirectAvailableAvailableAdd-onLow to high rangeYes
Cove
Direct onlineAvailableNot standardAdd-onStarter to high rangeYes

How to choose car cover in New Zealand

Four steps before you talk to an adviser.

  1. 1

    Decide cover type

    Comprehensive, third-party fire and theft, or third-party only. Match to the value of the vehicle.

  2. 2

    Pick your excess

    Higher excess = lower premium. Choose the highest excess you can pay out of pocket without stress.

  3. 3

    List the regular drivers

    Declare everyone who drives the car regularly. Higher-risk drivers add to the premium but protect future claims.

  4. 4

    Read exclusions and add-ons

    Optional cover for windscreen, agreed value vs market value, roadside and rental car. Check what is included before adding.

What car insurance covers in New Zealand

Car insurance in NZ comes in three main shapes — comprehensive, third-party fire and theft, and third-party only. Comprehensive covers your own vehicle plus liability for damage to others. Third-party fire and theft adds fire and theft of your own car. Third-party only covers liability — your own car repairs are out of pocket. NZ does not require compulsory motor insurance, but ACC only covers personal injury, so vehicle and property damage liability is real. Premium pricing varies sharply by driver age, vehicle value, location and excess level.

How we compare car insurance

We list every NZ car insurer on file with their product offering. Premium quotes are produced by a licensed adviser at quote time — we do not display indicative prices because they would mislead, given how much the number depends on individual factors. Our role is to surface the panel and the structural differences between insurers.

How it works

1

Tell us about you

A short questionnaire — typically takes about two minutes.

2

We refer you to a licensed adviser

Your enquiry is sent to Evolve Group Limited (FSP711891), our partner Financial Advice Provider.

3

Receive your comparison

The adviser sources quotes across a panel of NZ insurers or lenders and walks you through the options.

4

You stay in control

No obligation to apply, switch or buy. You decide whether to proceed.

Frequently asked questions

How much does car insurance cost in NZ?

Premiums depend on driver age and experience, vehicle make, model and value, where the car is parked overnight, claim history, and the excess level chosen. A young driver in central Auckland with a sports car pays multiples of what a middle-aged driver in a quiet suburb pays for the same cover.

Comprehensive vs third-party — which do I need?

Comprehensive covers damage to your own car plus damage you cause to others. Third-party only covers damage you cause to others — your own car is your problem. If your car is worth less than a couple of thousand dollars, third-party can make sense. Above that, comprehensive is usually worth it.

What is a no-claim bonus and how does it work?

A no-claim bonus is a discount that builds each policy year you go without claiming. Most insurers cap the bonus at around 60% off after 4-5 years. Some insurers offer "protected" no-claim bonus on top tiers, where one claim does not reset the discount.

Should I choose a high or low excess?

A higher excess reduces the premium but costs you more out of pocket at claim time. Pick the highest excess you can comfortably pay without using a credit card. Most insurers offer a range of excess levels from low to high.

Will my insurance cover a learner or restricted licence driver?

Yes, but premiums are higher and some insurers apply an additional young-driver excess on top of the base excess. Always list the regular drivers on the policy — claiming on an unlisted driver can lead to declined claims.

Are modifications covered?

Stock vehicles are covered as standard. Aftermarket modifications usually need to be declared and may attract higher premiums or be specifically excluded. Failing to declare modifications is a common reason for declined claims.

How does the claim process work?

Most insurers let you start a claim online or via app. You upload photos of the damage, complete a statement, and the insurer assigns an assessor or directs you to an approved repairer. Settlement is faster when fault is clear and the other driver is identified.

Can I get cover if my licence has lapsed?

Most insurers require all listed drivers to hold a current NZ or recognised overseas licence. Cover may be voidable if the driver at the time of the claim was unlicensed. Insurers do not all check the licence database — non-disclosure is risky regardless.

What if I switch insurers mid-term?

You can cancel an existing policy at any time and the insurer refunds the unused portion (minus any administration fee). Your no-claim bonus transfers if the new insurer recognises it — most mainstream insurers do.

Is car insurance compulsory in NZ?

No. NZ does not require compulsory third-party motor insurance. ACC covers personal injury from road accidents, but damage to other vehicles and property is your liability. Third-party cover is strongly recommended even when comprehensive is not in budget.

Related comparisons and guides